Another Win for MBM
Another Win for MBM – Federal Court of Canada Overturns Trademark Opposition Board and Recognizes the Overlap Between Alcohol and Tobacco (Cigars)
EMPRESSA CUBANA DEL TABACO dba CUBATABACO et al. v. TEQUILA CUERVO, S.A DE C.V. (2013) FC 1010
Scott Miller and Jonathan Roch, October 8, 2013
Factual Overview
Tequila Cuervo filed a Canadian trade-mark application for the trademark LAZARO COHIBA, disclaiming the word LAZARO. The application was based on proposed use for “alcoholic beverages, namely rum”. The application was opposed by Cubatabaco on grounds including that LAZARO COHIBA was not registrable based on the likelihood of confusion with the COHIBA registered trademarks for cigars and tobacco. On September 30, 2008, the Trademark Opposition Board concluded that “in view of the differences between the wares and trades of the parties and the fact that the opponents have not established an extensive reputation for their marks “ that the LAZARO COHIBA trademark was registrable.
Following the Trademark Opposition Board decision MBM was appointed as counsel to Cubatabaco. An appeal of the Board’s decision was filed by application to the Federal Court. The Federal Court overturned the Board’s decision and refused the registration of the LAZARO COHIBA trademark application.
Fame (Extensive Reputation) Demonstrating Without a Survey
MBM was able to demonstrate that the COHIBA trademarks are widely known across Canada by filing new evidence to establish that COHIBA has been referenced in films, television, music and other media, such as print magazines distributed in the United States and Canada. The fame of the COHIBA trademarks was established not by an expensive survey but by creatively revealing that pop media has used COHIBA cigars to demonstrate social status and wealth. The decision is equally important because it recognizes that for some iconic brands, personal ownership or use of the product is not essential to the awareness of the trademark. Click here to view a copy of the decision.
Conclusion
There are multiple ways for trademark professionals to establish confusion. While in some incidents expensive surveys may be necessary that will not always be the case.
Please contact Scott Miller or Jonathan Roch for more information.
