Supreme Court Asked to Reconsider Decision to Invalidate Viagra Patent

By Suzanne Hof - November 16 2012

cb photo_91_4f19cd1eeada2

Pfizer Canada Inc. (Pfizer) has asked the Supreme Court of Canada to reconsider its decision to invalidate their Canadian Patent No. 2,163,446, the patent that provided Pfizer with a monopoly for its multi-million dollar erectile dysfunction drug, Viagra.

Pfizer has taken the position that the Court “accidentally granted a remedy in this appeal that exceeds its jurisdiction.”  The proceedings in question were initiated as an application under the Patented Medicines (Notice of Compliance) Regulations, the outcome of which is typically not to determine invalidity or infringement, but rather to determine whether a notice of compliance should or should not be granted.  

In the present case, the present proceedings were initiated as an application for an order prohibiting Teva Canada Limited from obtaining a notice of compliance for its generic version of Viagra.  Pfizer has therefore taken the position that the Supreme Court was acting outside its jurisdiction in its finding of invalidity.  

In particular, Pfizer has applied for an order to amend the Supreme Court’s recent judgment “by replacing the words ‘and Patent 2,153,446 is declared void’ with the words ‘the application below is dismissed and the Order of the Federal Court dated June 18, 2009, prohibiting the Minister from issuing notice of compliance to the appellant is hereby set aside’.”  In the alternative, Pfizer has applied for a re-hearing on the issue of remedy.

We will, of course, be following these proceedings and posting updates.

The read the previous article on this please visit: If There is No Quid Then There Can Be No Quo - Pfizer's Viagra patent invalidated by Supreme Court of Canada

If you have any questions please contact Suzanne Hof

 

Submit to DiggSubmit to FacebookSubmit to Google BookmarksSubmit to StumbleuponSubmit to TwitterSubmit to LinkedIn

cb photo 103 56182ad806034

RANDALL MARUSYK

Partner


Randall is a partner of the firm and has been certified as a specialist in all areas of Canadian IP Law.
MBM read_more_btn

 

MBM logo

About MBM

 The process of invention is complete only with the IP protection provided in law. That's where MBM comes in. We match our clients' creative thinking with the creative protection needed to achieve their goals.Read More About MBM

Methods of Medical Treatment in Canada

Claims directed to methods of medical treatment are considered to be directed to non-statutory subject matter...Read More